Reviews

  • Cleverly constructed and elegantly written. It's both an engaging human story and a place for wider topical observations. Bring on Spring

    Evening Standard
  • If Ali Smith's four quartets in, and about, time do not endure to rank among <b>the most original, consoling and inspiring</b> of the artistic responses to 'this mad and bitter mess' of the present, then we will have plunged into an even bleaker mid-winter than people often fear

    Financial Times
  • Smith is a specialist by now in using a quizzical, feather-light prose style to interrogate the heaviest of material...throughout <i>Winter</i>, grief and pain are transfigured, sometimes lastingly, by luminous moments of humour, insight and connection... <b>Even in the bleak midwinter, Smith is evergreen</b>

    Telegraph
  • A novel of <b>great ferocity, tenderness and generosity of spirit</b> that you feel Dickens would have recognised...Smith is engaged in an extended process of mythologizing the present states of Britain... <b>Luminously beautiful</b>

    Observer
  • <b>Graceful</b>... That <b>trademark mischievous wit and wordplay</b>, a joyful reminder of the most basic, elemental delights of reading ... Infused with some <b>much-needed humour, happiness and hope</b>

    Independent
  • A capacious, generous shapeshifter of a novel taking in Greenham Common and Barbara Hepworth, Shakespeare and global migration, it juxtaposes art with nature and protest with apathy, finding surprising alliances in a family riven by feuds. It's a book with Christmas at its heart, in all its familiarity and estrangement: about time, and out of time, like the festival itself

    The Guardian
  • Dazzling second instalment of Ali Smith's seasonal quartet

    The Daily Telegraph
  • A book I can't wait to read for Christmas

    The Observer
  • Relish this instalment

    The Times
  • I would like to be given Winter for Christmas

    The Observer
  • And now looking forward to [Ali Smith's] Winter

    Gordon Brown
  • And the book I'd most like to find in my Christmas stocking is Ali Smith's Winter

    The Observer
  • Finally, under the tree this year I'm hoping to find Ali Smith's Winter

    The Observer
  • It's a brisk, frosty walk under skies that could open at any moment revealing anything but snow

    The Observer
  • A book I'd like to be given for Christmas: Winter by Ali Smith

    The Observer
  • It takes you on a journey through time - Christmases past and present in a Dickensian way, but brings you bang up to the present - how can we live our lives and keep our memories and how do we find the truth? It is uplifting and miraculous with plenty of surprises along the way. It is vintage Smith

    Jackie Kay
  • "Winter" is an insubordinate folk tale, with echoes of the fiction of Iris Murdoch and Angela Carter... <b>There are</b> <b>few</b> <b>writers</b> <b>on</b> <b>the</b> <b>world</b> <b>stage who are producing fiction this offbeat and</b> <b>alluring</b>... [Ali Smith] intends to send a chill up your shanks and she succeeds, jubilantly... Her dialogue is a series of pine cones flung at rosy cheeks

    The New York Times
  • Smith is routinely <b>brilliant, knowing, masterful</b>... The light inside this great novelist's gorgeous snow globe is utterly original, and it definitely illuminates

    New York Times Book Review
  • The only preparation required to savor the Scottish writer Ali Smith's virtuosic "Winter" is to pay attention to the world we've recently been living in...What Smith has achieved in her cycle so far is exactly what we need artists to do in disorienting times: make sense of events, console us, show us how we got here, help us believe that we will find our way through...<b>Smith gives us a potent, necessary source of sustenance that speaks directly to our age</b>...Yet we, like her characters, are past the winter solstice now - the darkest part of the coldest season done. From here on out, we're headed toward the light...It doesn't feel that way, I know. But in the midst of "Winter," each page touched with human grace, you might just begin to believe

    Boston Globe
  • Winter is a stunning meditation on a complex, emotional moment in history

    TIME
  • <b>Ali Smith is flat-out brilliant</b>, and she's on fire these days...You can trust Smith to snow us once again with her uncanny ability to combine brainy playfulness with depth, topicality with timelessness, and complexity with accessibility while delivering an impassioned defence of human decency and art

    NPR
  • The stunningly original Smith again breaks every conceivable narrative rule; reflecting her longstanding affinity for Modernism, what she gives us instead is a stylistically innovative cultural bricolage that celebrates the ecstasy of artistic influence. It demands and richly rewards close attention. [Autumn and Winter] each add to Smith's growing collection of glittering literary paving stones, along a path that's hopefully leading toward the Nobel she deserves. In the interim, we can (re)read "Winter" - and eagerly await the coming of "Spring"

    Minneapolis Journal Sentinel
  • One of the rarest creatures in the world: <b>a really fearless novelist</b>...her prose is melodic, associative, wise, sometimes maddening...'she shares with Mantel and Ishiguro a sense of human caution, a need to understand, a wariness of the high-handedly authorial. All write with the humility of adulthood

    Chicago Tribune
  • The second in Smith's quartet of seasonal novels displays her mastery at weaving allusive magic into the tragicomedies of British people and politics...<b>a bleak, beautiful tale</b> greater than the sum of its references

    Vulture
  • An engaging novel due to the ecstatic energy of Smith's writing, which is always present on the page

    Publishers Weekly
  • A sprightly, digressive, intriguing fandango on life and time

    Kirkus Reviews
  • These individuals converge to confront each other in the big shabby house, like characters in a Chekhov play. At first, hellish implosion looms. Slowly, erratically, connection creeps in. Lux quietly mediates. Ire softens. Sophia at last eats something. Art resees Nature..."Winter" gives the patient reader a colorful, witty - yes, warming - divertissement

    San Francisco Chronicle
  • With Iris and Lux as catalysts, scenes from Christmas past unfold, and our narrow views of Sophia and Art widen and deepen, filled with the secrets and substance of their histories, even as the characters themselves seem to expand. As in Sophia's case, for Art this enlargement is announced by a hallucination - "not a real thing," as Lux tells Iris, whose response speaks for the book's own expansive spirit: "Where would we be without our ability to see beyond what it is we're supposed to be seeing?"

    The Minneapolis Star Tribune